So, You Have the Slide Presentation and Guided Notes. Now What?

The one who does the work in a classroom does the learning. If students are copying notes from a screen, what can teachers easily add to instruction that facilitates student thinking about content?

Back in the 1900s, when I was in middle and high school, social studies often involved reading the textbook chapter and answering the questions at the end. The 21st century version is the slide presentation and guided notes. If you’ve spent any time in a Facebook group for teachers or on Teachers Pay Teachers, you know presentations aligned with the Course and Exam Description from the College Board are incredibly popular. Teachers often give students copies to annotate and make notes on during class or a sheet of notes with strategically placed blanks that students fill in during the lecture.

For a variety of reasons (look for more about that in upcoming posts), my lessons don’t include the CED-aligned presentation and guided notes like those. But I’m not saying they can’t be effective. I have some fresh anecdotal evidence that 21st century students can learn a lot from it and its ancestor. Last year, my school had a section of AP Human Geography students who had a substitute teacher for five months. The substitute chose not to use my lessons, so I provided questions based on the textbook or videos for students to answer, basically the textbook-and-questions version of guided notes. The new teacher who was hired in mid-February used a few of the activities I shared with her, but as a teacher new to teaching the subject, she mostly filled class time with showing her students a presentation while they filled out guided notes. Her students earned scores on the AP exam that were similar to those of my own students, which caused me some angst when scores were released in early July.

Of course, I was thrilled that so many of the students in the class without a permanent teacher for much of the year qualified for college credit. It wasn’t their fault they had a sub for so long. So I went searching for the source of my distress. I think what bothered me was the possibility that I was putting a lot of time and energy into creating learning experiences that weren’t necessarily reflected in the outcome I was using to measure my success. If the score on the AP exam was the measure, the students who spent much of the year reading, watching videos, and answering questions had done just as well as my students.

I am grateful for my wise friend and fellow AP teacher who pointed out that while the AP exam measures particular knowledge and skills, it does not measure every worthwhile thing that happens in a classroom. My students had opportunities to be creative and collaborate with their peers. They had discussions many of them seemed to find engaging. They even had fun while learning, often because of lesson plans from APA’s Teachers of Psychology in Secondary Schools, Population Education, or games I created using Flippity. I believe these things matter.

Unfortunately, the reality of teaching a subject such as AP Human Geography or AP Psychology is that the teacher may not have taken more than one college course in the subject, if that. Some are hired too late in the summer to attend an AP Summer Institute during which they are given training and resources to teach AP. Whether new or experienced, most teachers don’t have nearly enough time during the contract day to do much more than make photocopies (after finding the only copier in the building that isn’t broken), post everything on the Learning Management System, and enter grades. In addition to preparing to teach multiple courses, teachers’ days are filled with attending meetings, providing data to admin, covering classes for absent teachers, doing duty, and contacting parents.

So let’s say you have the CED-aligned presentation and guided notes, and you want to add an opportunity for students to do some thinking. Read on to find out what you can add that is easy to implement and requires minimal prep on your part beyond reading this post.

STRATEGY #1: WHAT DO YOU THINK? NOW MAKE IT BETTER.

Being able to answer essential questions using content learned in our class is the takeaway many of us want for our students long after they’ve taken the AP exam. The CED already has these, and you can use them to activate students’ prior knowledge and reflect on their learning. For example, the AP Psychology CED suggests the essential question (EQ) Why don’t people always make good decisions? for unit 2 (pdf pg. 56). This is perfect for teaching 2.2 Thinking, Problem-Solving, Judgments, and Decision-Making. An essential question suggested by the CED for unit 3 in AP Human Geography (pdf pg. 64) is How and why do cultural ideas, practices, and innovations change or disappear over time? Content learned in 3.6 Contemporary Causes of Diffusion helps students use what they learn in geography to answer this.

Instruct students to write the essential question at the top of their notes and answer it in two or three sentences using only what they already know. (Note: this can include what they have learned related to this EQ from a prior lesson and/or homework, and you can assess their understanding just by reading what they wrote. There’s no need to collect the work - just read it over their shoulder.) After the lesson, students can revise their answer using concepts or processes or examples they learned during the lesson. The revised answer could use the terms from strategy #2 (connect-defend-question). Then they can trade papers with a partner, with each person identifying an idea that their own work doesn’t include.

On the day you teach 2.2 Thinking, Problem-Solving, Judgments, and Decision-Making in AP Psychology, a student’s first answer to Why don’t people always make good decisions? might be “Because they’re emotional or don’t think it through.” After the lesson, the revision might add heuristics and sunk cost fallacy, along with an example like continuing to watch a bad movie because you already paid for the ticket.

On the day you teach 3.6 Contemporary Causes of Diffusion in AP Human Geography, a student’s first answer to How and why do cultural ideas, practices, and innovations change or disappear over time? might be “People move and bring their culture with them.” Their initial answer might even include the term relocation diffusion. The revision might add time-space convergence, the internet, and globalization, with an example like a particular trend that starts in one country and diffuses worldwide in days because of TikTok can make cultures in distant places more similar.

STRATEGY #2: CONNECT-DEFEND-QUESTION

My students are curious and capable, but the only study method most of them know—much less use—is to reread notes and use flash cards to match words to definitions. Then they wonder why their mind “goes blank” on a test. One of my favorite strategies for helping them practice retrieval is list-group-label. Students write down 15-20 “vocabulary” terms (list) and then categorize (group) them based on something specific that they have in common (label). Connect-defend-question extends list-group-label and can be implemented when you are done teaching a topic. Have students explain the connection between two terms in two different categories and then defend the connection to a peer, ideally one they have to get out of their seat to talk to.

For example, let’s say you’re teaching 2.2 Thinking, Problem-Solving, Judgments, and Decision-Making in AP Psychology. A student might choose mental set, priming, framing, gambler’s fallacy, and sunk cost fallacy and label or categorize them as Decision-Making. Another category, Thinking, might include concepts, prototypes, schema, assimilation, and accommodation. (Note that it is possible a student could place mental set in the Thinking or Problem-Solving category. The student’s justification for the placement is what should matter.)

Suppose a student picks concept from the Thinking category and sunk cost fallacy from the Decision-Making category. They might write: “A person’s concept of commitment can make them keep investing in something that isn’t working because quitting feels like it doesn’t fit what they believe a committed person does.” After the student shares with a partner, the partner could ask a question such as “Where’s the sunk cost in this example? What might they have already put in that they can’t get back?”

In AP Human Geography, you might be teaching 3.6 Contemporary Causes of Diffusion. A student might place urbanization and globalization in the category Large-Scale Causes of Contemporary Diffusion and internet and time-space convergence in the category Technological Changes. Then they might choose globalization and internet and write: “The internet speeds up globalization because ideas such as trends on TikTok can reach people on the other side of the world almost instantly. A TikTok trend that starts in Seoul can show up in Dallas, which can eventually make cultures in different places more connected and more similar.” After the student shares with a partner, the partner could ask, “Which came first, globalization or the internet?” or “Is this TikTok trend an example of contagious or hierarchical diffusion?”

Teacher moves here could include an “I do” in which you model choosing terms, constructing categories, and being a partner who asks a follow-up question. Consider using a topic different from the one you teach on this day. While students share with a partner, you can circulate, listening to student discussion and supporting partners in asking follow-up questions, which can be challenging for many students.

STRATEGY #3: DRAW IT

Pairing words with visuals is called dual coding, and research on the “drawing effect” suggests that students remember more when they draw a concept than when they only write it, even when the drawings are quick and not artistic. After you teach a concept, students sketch it in their notes, using labels as necessary but not definitions, then trade with a partner who explains what the drawing shows.

A student who has just learned 2.2 Thinking, Problem-Solving, Judgments, and Decision-Making in AP Psych might draw a movie ticket stub next to a screen, with a frowning stick figure still in the seat, and label it sunk cost fallacy. To show schema, assimilation, and accommodation, a student might draw a file folder with a label on the tab. A new item slides into the folder (assimilation), while another doesn’t fit and needs a new folder (accommodation). The photo that accompanies this post demonstrates how a student drew various devolutionary factors after we discussed each during a lesson in APHG on 4.8 Defining Devolutionary Factors.

Teacher moves with dual coding can include modeling how to turn a concept or relationship into a visual representation. Think aloud as you decide what to include, what to leave out, and how to represent the relationship between ideas. Emphasize that the goal isn't to create an artistic drawing or decorate notes. The goal is to make thinking visible.

BEYOND THE SLIDES AND THE SCORE

Last year’s experience taught me that it was possible for students who had spent five months of the academic year reading or watching videos and answering questions and the rest of it filling in guided notes from a slide presentation to earn college credit. I’m genuinely happy for them. But the AP exam doesn’t measure creativity, collaboration, discussion, movement, or learning games, and those experiences are a big part of why I love teaching and why I think students remember my class. The strategies outlined above can add discussion, collaboration, and creativity to your instruction without adding to your workload. Keep your slide presentation and guided notes…but let students do some of the thinking. For your convenience in implementing them, this downloadable reference handout summarizes the three strategies.

WHAT MIGHT YOUR ADMINISTRATOR LOVE ABOUT THIS?

Your admin may love that you are using research-based strategies such as retrieval practice and the drawing effect. They probably appreciate that you are activating prior knowledge and modeling the activity with an I do. Engagement in the lesson increases because students are discussing content, asking each other questions, and moving around the room when they get up to share with a partner. Afterwards, you can tell your admin that you read about these strategies on this blog. Your administrator loves a teacher who is a lifelong learner, and their evaluation instrument probably rewards it.

EXTRA CREDIT

Read an article about the science of learning, including retrieval practice and dual coding, here. Read research about the drawing effect here. If you’re an AP Psych teacher who wants a lesson plan for 2.3 Introduction to Memory (A.4., automatic vs. effortful processing), click here to read Teaching Current Directions in Psychological Science, a column in the Association for Psychological Science Observer, which has the suggested procedure and processing the activity with students. Feel free to use these slides I made that will help you conduct the activity in your classroom. (Note that I changed the red text the article suggested to white text on a black background to enhance readability.)

TALK TO ME!

After 31 years in the classroom, I’m still learning, and I would love to hear from you. What’s one low-prep strategy you use to get your students thinking beyond the notes? What happens in your classroom that an exam score could never capture?

Next
Next

There Can Be More To a Question Than The Correct Answer.